Arthur's character arc is very disappointing.

Just finished the game, thought it was great, great ending.

However, I found that Arthur went from a formidable gunslinging badass to a lost puppy, mindlessly following Dutch into whatever half-baked scheme he had put together.

That would be acceptable if he were playing a more "Micah-esque" role in the gang, but he knows and actively calls Dutch out on his behaviour and poor strategies.

He Insists...

Despite all this, he only manages to get people out from camp one by one, weakly suggesting that they leave. Never actively doing anything to stop Dutch from costing them everything. He never escapes being under Dutch's thumb, and that ultimately costs him everything.

But maybe that's what made it such a great story. What did you all think/feel when the ending was revealed to you?