Magma gear vs Divine gear

As the title says, had some questions on the mentioned gear sets. I finally got enough cooking clogs to make a few sets of the troll shoes, and ready to roll into the divine stuff immediately after. However, I heard mention on these forums that 2 of the 4 pieces of magma were superior, and wanted to get some confirmation on what I should be looking for before I roll into an irreversible situation. Any pointers on the best path forward?